The short answer
- Pour-over gives a clean, light cup that shows off fruity, floral coffees.
- French press gives a heavier, richer cup and is harder to get wrong.
- Pour-over: medium-fine grind, 1:16, 94 °C, about 3 minutes.
- French press: coarse grind, 1:15, 95 °C, 4 minutes.
The difference in the cup
A pour-over runs water through a paper filter. The paper holds back the oils and fine particles, so the cup is clean and light and the acidity and aroma come through clearly. It suits light roasts from origins like Ethiopia or Kenya.
A French press steeps the grounds in water, then a metal mesh separates them. Oils and fine particles stay in the cup, so it has more body and a rounder, heavier taste. It suits chocolatey, nutty coffees from Brazil or Colombia.
Effort and equipment
The French press is the more forgiving of the two. You pour all the water at once, wait four minutes and press. There is little to get wrong.
A pour-over asks for more attention: a slow, steady pour in circles, ideally from a gooseneck kettle, and a scale helps. In return you control every part of the brew.
Whichever you pick, a burr grinder improves the cup more than any upgrade to the brewer itself.
How to brew a pour-over
Grind medium-fine, like table salt. Use a ratio of 1:16 (15 g of coffee to 240 g of water) and water at about 94 °C.
- Rinse the paper filter with hot water and tip the water away.
- Add the grounds and pour twice their weight in water. Wait 40 seconds while the coffee blooms.
- Pour the rest in slow circles, keeping the bed covered.
- The drawdown should finish around three minutes. Faster means grind finer; slower, coarser.
How to brew a French press
Grind coarse, like raw sugar. Use a ratio of 1:15 (20 g of coffee to 300 g of water) and water at about 95 °C.
- Add the grounds, pour all the water and let it stand for four minutes.
- Break the crust with a spoon and skim off the foam and floating grounds.
- Press slowly and pour straight away. Coffee left on the grounds keeps extracting and turns bitter.
Which one to choose
Choose a French press if you want a full cup with little fuss, brew for several people at once or drink coffee with milk. Choose a pour-over if you like light, fruity coffees and enjoy the ritual.
Many people end up owning both. The brew guide in every Koftera gift box covers both methods, plus AeroPress and moka pot, with a calculator for the right dose.
Questions
- Is pour-over or French press stronger?
- French press usually tastes stronger because oils and fine particles stay in the cup. Strength mostly depends on the ratio, though, not the method.
- Can I use the same grind for both?
- Not well. Pour-over needs medium-fine grounds; French press needs coarse ones, or the cup turns bitter and muddy.